Sit down with your partner.
1. Compare outlines. First, compare the outlines you developed for the essay. Did you both extract the same, or similar, outlines for the document?
2. Identify arguments. Go through your document page-by-page, and identify those places where you felt the author was attempting to make an argument or point that was important to their essay.
3. Grade arguments. For each of the arguments you identified, compare and contrast your grading. Consolidate your argument list, so that the markup on both papers reflect the complete set of points the author was trying to make.
